Review Comment

History of Early Christianity

May 26, 2015

Castelli, Elizabeth
History of Early Christianity

Professor Castelli is one of the best professors I have encountered at Columbia University. I think I am not alone in this opinion given the number of students who have taken her more than once.

As a person and a Professor, Castelli is more interested in teaching and you learning then getting caught up the minutia of you knowing every text and detail by heart. She understands that we have a significant workload and wants to help her students succeed in the class. This does not mean she lets us off or out of work, but that throughout the semester she works with us and is flexible. She expects a lot out of her students, however none of it is unreasonable and I probably learned more efficiently in her class than any other.

I came to this class with ZERO knowledge of Christianity or religion, of the history of the period we were looking at or the cultures. In that way I was way behind my classmates, however Castelli made the subject approachable and engaging. She focused on a very palatable cross section of the period that was not overwhelming and then asked thought provoking questions that really encouraged us to bring these ideas together in a way that made sense to us.

In addition Prof. Castelli is kind and very generous with her time – eager to know her students and help them. Her classes are enjoyable. The end result is that even those texts that I did not get to read entirely during the semester I will read on my own because she sparked my interest.

I have read some less then favorable reviews of Prof. Castelli and I am somewhat baffled. Yes she has strong opinions on some topics but none of them were alienating and she really encouraged students to bring their own ideas and experiences to the table. Our class was made up of Jews and Christians of various strains. We went through some very touchy and at times difficulty materials and at no time did anyone get offended or ostracized.

I think Castelli is the sort of teacher who attracts rather than promotes and highly recommend her.

For full transparency I received an A- in this course.

Workload:

Lots of reading and weekly responses (about 500 words)
Two papers (1500-2000 words)
Final exam

May 09, 2003

Castelli, Elizabeth
History of Early Christianity

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I think she is an amazing professor and this is the best class i have taken so far at Columbia or Barnard. I actually looked forward to going to each class because her lectures and our discussions were so interesting and fun. You do a lot of reading, but it is definitely worth it and I learned a lot. She is very approachable and nice. Take this class!

Workload:

Lots of reading, response papers each week, two long papers and a final

December 17, 2002

Castelli, Elizabeth
History of Early Christianity

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Interesting exposure to early Christian texts, but when I say exposure I mean only that. Lecture had very little structure, and while that meant a lot of time for discussion, it also meant feeling like I didn't learn very much and being pretty bored in class most of the time. Professor Castelli is very accomodating and kind but it was hard to get into her class because a lot of the readings were deathly boring and she gave them little historical or social context which may have made them more exciting. If you don't know anything about Christianity, this class will probably only confuse you since the whole point of early Christianity is that it is diverse and multi-faceted and not-yet canonized. Luckily, the course was not too demanding aside from doing the reading.

Workload:

Weekly reading response papers, 2 longer papers, final exam. Lots of reading but you don't have to do it all, especially the secondary source materials.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section