Review Comment

[ARCH V1020y] Introduction To Architectural Design and Visual Culture

December 05, 2014

Rouhe, Todd Silver_nugget
[ARCH V1020y] Introduction To Architectural Design and Visual Culture

Professor Rouhe (or simply Todd, as his students call him) is hilariously sassy and overwhelming amicable. He effectively taught the basics of model-making and hand drafting, emphasizing a clean and careful technique. In terms of project content, he provides explicit guidelines but is intentionally vague in describing what the final product should be. In this way, he allows the student to wield tremendous artistic license (which is particularly refreshing for SEAS students like myself). He provides helpful and constructive criticism during desk crits and pinups, but is careful to let the student work through his/her own ideas. With the exception of final pinups for a particular project, reviews were meant to help students at any stage in their creative process. The overall emphasis seemed to be on a step-by-step progression of ideas.

Workload:

This course is a major time commitment. Expect to spend many hours in studio, especially in preparation for final pinups. The key is dividing a project into small chunks. There are four main projects and one site visit (during the class period). Honestly, I don't think anyone knows exactly how your grade is calculated in this class, but from what I understand, Todd wants to see a concentrated effort on the part of the student.

September 08, 2011

Schwartzman, Madeline Silver_nugget
[ARCH V1020y] Introduction To Architectural Design and Visual Culture

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I am not sure why the reviews below are quite so positive. Yes, I agree that Madeline is a nice person, but she is a terrible teacher! She changes her mind constantly, which is very inconvenient when you've spent time (and usually money) changing something to make it the way she wants, only to have her tell you that you shouldn't have changed it the very next class. I spent most of my time in the class being confused on the content and point of the assignments, as she rarely took the time to fully explain these things. The one good thing I have to say is she does reward effort...if you put in way more effort than should be required in an intro level class intended for non-majors.

Workload:

If you want to do well, a lot!

May 05, 2011

Schwartzman, Madeline Silver_nugget
[ARCH V1020y] Introduction To Architectural Design and Visual Culture

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Madeleine is a gem at this university. A gift to this world. I have never encountered a creative genius who is so motivating and demanding and inspiring all at the same time. She is overflowing with ideas, and sometimes she spits them out so fast, you can't figure out how she jumped from one to the other. She is kind and encouraging, and demands continuous reevaluation. The course demanded time and thought, but that is exactly what is necessary in the field. I am now pursuing architecture because of this woman, though I don't think I will ever encounter someone like her again.

Workload:

sufficient, but if you love it, you'll love every minute of the work.

September 04, 2009

Schwartzman, Madeline Silver_nugget
[ARCH V1020y] Introduction To Architectural Design and Visual Culture

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Madeline is great! Her class can be frustrating, but it is worth it. She is a teacher, a friend, and a muse.

Workload:

Workload is tough, but worth it in the end.

April 28, 2008

French, Anda
[ARCH V1020y] Introduction To Architectural Design and Visual Culture

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

This class is a very interesting introduction to architecture and forces you to see things through an entirely new perspective. The second two projects for this class were more exciting than the first, mainly because it was more hands-on and more related to architecture.

While Anda is helpful at times, the way in which she conveys what she wants is rather convoluted. She expects us to extract all information from the vague directions in the project assignment sheets, and when she is asked to clarify the assignment, she tells us to refer back to the assignment sheet.

Additionally, be prepared to face incredibly harsh critics- most of them were her classmates from architecture school. An analogy for review day is- swimming in a tank of piranhas, and Anda being one of them. If you think you'll be all alone defending your project in front of the panel of critics, you will be. She does not attempt to save you from any attack from the critics, and attacks you, as well.

The class is enjoyable, but be prepared to come back feeling awfully miserable from a critique.

Workload:

3 main projects, the last project involves extensive model making. Also be prepared to spend a lot of money at Pearl/Janoff's

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture 2013 Spring / 2
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Madeline Schwartzman 2013 Spring MW / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Richard Rouhe 2012 Fall TR / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Madeline Schwartzman 2012 Spring MW / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Madeline Schwartzman 2011 Spring MW / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Richard Rouhe 2010 Spring TR / 9:00-10:50 AM 2
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Madeline Schwartzman 2010 Spring MW / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Todd Rouhe 2009 Spring MW / 11:00-12:50 PM 2
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Madeline Schwartzman 2009 Spring MW / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Gernot Riether 2004 Spring MW / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Maria Gray 2003 Spring MW / 1:10- 3:00 PM 1
ARCB / ARCH ARCB ARCH V1020: Intro-Architecture Design/Vis Culture: Intro Architecture Design Vis Culture Maria Gray 2002 Spring F / 10:00-11:50 AM 1