Review Comment

[Religion V3307] Muslims in Diaspora

January 04, 2018

Rashid, Hussein
[Religion V3307] Muslims in Diaspora

I took this class after reading the previous review and after speaking to other students who had previously taken this class, and now feel it necessary to share my experience, which was somewhat less positive this semester than it seems students had in previous semesters. While Hussein Rashid is not a bad professor and is clearly an extremely intelligent man with a lot of interesting information to share, this course is painfully disorganized, to the point where I feel like I came away from it with little understanding of what the point was supposed to be. To be clear, this is not to say I didn't learn anything - I got a lot of interesting tidbits of information from this class, but the overall structure lacks clear cohesion, which was frustrating, and made it hard for me to sum up major themes of the course in my writing assignments. Professor Rashid often seemed to get stuck on certain topics (for example, gender identity - once Professor Rashid had a TA lead a class in which all we did the entire time of 1 hour and 15 minutes was read quotes about 9/11 and debate whether we thought a man or a woman had said them) and it was hard for me to understand how these topics even connected back to the broader theme of the course (a theme which I don't even feel able to sum up in this review.) The readings for this course were often only vaguely connected to the lecture topics, and the discussion sections were completely unhinged from everything else. (For two weeks, my TA had us write characters for a play, for example. We never did anything else with these characters, they were not related to any reading we did or anything we talked about in the course. My character writing group spent a lot of time looking up different causes of gluten intolerance - definitely interesting, but not at all what I thought I was getting into when I registered for this course.) Basically, while I did learn new things in this course, I feel that there is a clear issue in any course where a student walks away unable to summarize what she spent the last semester learning about.

Further, this course is NOT easy. The grading is done by the TAs, which may explain some of the disparity between my experience and the experience of others, but I found the grading to be extremely harsh, and the standards for grading to be unclear. The professor and the TA spent a lot of time talking about grades, and we in fact spent multiple lectures reading through random papers and editing them (painfully slowly, and again not what I pay $70,000 in tuition to learn about in my religion courses) but I was still never really clear how to improve my own work/ write assignments that would earn good grades in this course. There are weekly 1 page reflections, which I felt expected a ridiculous amount of effort for a 1 page paper - come up with a thesis that ties back to the "main themes of the course" (still unclear what they were) and demonstrates that you have done all the assigned readings (often huge amounts of dense, dense reading.) I spent HOURS agonizing over each paper to earn passing grades, and I am a humanities major who has never struggled with writing or response papers in all my many other classes that require them. So be warned, while this is not necessarily a reason to not take this course, it is not easy, and a rather large time commitment.

I do not mean with this review to completely turn students off from this course, but I do want to present what I think to be an honest critique of the course, and make sure students don't just waltz in expecting a fantastic and easy A semester. I think there are better designed classes to take if you are interested in any of the subjects this course touches on, it may be worth looking into them as well.

Workload:

Weekly response papers, a 4 page midterm paper, and a 6 page final paper - doesn't sound like a lot of work, but given that this class is basically about nothing and the grading standards are insanely high, you will have to work!

December 12, 2016

Rashid, Hussein
[Religion V3307] Muslims in Diaspora

This class was honestly the most interesting class that you could ever take. The content was so much fun and every lecture and seminar flew by. Professor Rashid is the BEST professor that I have ever had. He is genuinely the nicest man you will ever meet. He is definitely a feminist and is so personable. He plays music before class everyday (long live his rap tunes), and makes the funniest jokes during lecture. He's absolutely hysterical. Being in class felt like you were with a friend. I genuinely never wanted this class to end. He is the best lecturer Columbia has to offer. If possible, TAKE ANY CLASS WITH HIM. You will not regret it. Plus, it's insanley easy to get an A+ in this class. The assignments are super easy. It's a short paper of 250 works a week and you can write about whatever you want - just make sure you put in a lot of quotes from whatever you were assigned to read. Engaging with the text is something he likes to see, but do not summarize your readings. I was able to get a 3/3 or 4/3 on every paper and a 30/30 on the midterm paper. It's not hard. Plus, he offers a total of 10 points worth of extra credit during the semester. And as if that isn't easy enough, he takes your 10 highest weekly papers and drops the rest. By the time week 10 rolled around I already had a 3/3 or 4/3 on everything and I did not need to do anymore of the weekly papers, which was super nice because I was then able to focus on my other classes. This class is structured to make sure you get an A+. TL;DR - Best professor you'll ever have, amazing class, super interesting, really funny, easy A+. Take it!

Workload:

Weekly reading assignments 2-3 articles (super enjoyable!), weekly SHORT papers (250 words), one midterm (paper - 4 pages), one final (paper - 6 pages).

May 08, 2013

Ewing, Katherine
[Religion V3307] Muslims in Diaspora

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I took her Muslims in Diaspora class and I deeply regret it!!!!!!! The readings are quite interesting, however the delivery of the material is absolutely awful! She manages to make everything tediously boring, in addition she tends to jump from one topic to another. However, the most annoying part was how unapproachable and unaccommodating she is to students...don't even bother visiting her during her office. And I just have to say, for a class of 20 students she REALLY doesn't need a TA grading everything!!!!
Do yourself a favor and stay away from this class/this professor!!!!!!!!

Workload:

in class quizzes, 3 papers (4-5 page), class participation, blog posts on Courseworks, take-home final

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
RELI / RELI RELI RELI V3307: Muslims in Diaspora Katherine Ewing 2012 Spring TR / 4:10- 5:25 PM 1