Jay was a wonderful teacher who was able to bring lots of energy and enthusiasm to our 9:00am class. Although he usually expected just enough participation and engagement for it to be annoying, his teaching method was generally good. He focuses not on the detailed level of writing, but more on the overall structure, clarity of argument, and use of external sources. Moreover, his comments can sometimes seem frustrating or arbitrary, but after time I came to realize how truly spot on his comments always were. I'll admit that I had come from a high school with an extremely rigorous English program which graded at or above Jay's expectations consistently for years, so I had been prepared (in fact, Jay went to the same high school with the same writing program, and his mother still teaches there!). However, I'll concede that his standards might be tough (though not unreasonable) for any student who does not already have solid writing skills. For me, it was not difficult to get a solid A in the class, and I'm sure that any student that feels as if their English preparation in high school was adequate can do the same. I would definitely recommend Jay to anyone who can get him, not only because he is an excellent teacher but also because he just a awesome person.