here you will find a slew of positive reviews, gushing about this professor. do not be fooled. my complaint is basic: i received A's on all of the written assignments for this class, and was a consistent and lively participant in class discussion. somehow, to kampen, this means i deserved a B+. of course, i am disputing this grade. as i am forced to entertain her excuses for giving me a B+, i will just say that personal resentment, and other geriatric inclinations, are to blame. and this, is unacceptable. if you want a professor who is cute and cuddly, kampen is your woman. but don't think that you can work hard and be secure that you will receive the grade you earned. be prepared.
Tallie, as she affectionately signs her emails, is one of the most personable and approachable professors I have come across in my career at Columbia. Her lectures, though on a topic I didn't really appreciate, were fun because she was so passionate about the material. (We even took trips to the Met - once to see the new Greek and Roman Galleries). Writing the papers was hard, but she was accessible to aid in your research since it is such an obscure and unexplored topic.
Tally was absolutely fabulous!!! If you get a chance to take a class with her, consider yourself amazingly lucky! She is intelligent and well-spoken and has a great sense of humor. She reconfirmed my decision to be a Women's and Gender Studies major. She was excellent about responding quickly to email, answering questions, providing feedback on rough drafts of papers, etc. Her syllabus was well-organized and she stuck to it, so you always knew what was expected for each day of class. She was also great about soliciting students' feedback and responding to our needs (such as extending paper deadlines and asking us which reading assignments we liked most and least so she could revise the syllabus for next year). And she graded/returned papers very quickly! Tally was understanding and approachable and made class interesting and fun. I never wanted to miss her class and I never had trouble staying awake in it, and I actually enjoyed writing the papers for this class and I liked the reading assignments (with the exception of maybe 1 or 2 texts). I learned so much in this class while really having a blast. The only thing I'd ask Tally to change about the structure of this class is to have her be in charge of leading the discussion (as she did in the beginning of the semester, but later she switched to assigning student discussion leaders... and I liked it better when she guided the discussion because I felt it was more focused that way). But really, this was the best Women's Studies class I've ever taken and I'd definitely recommend it!! I miss Tally already! Take her class!
i didn't really understand what this class was about but it's a major requirement and sounded interesting. tally revamped it and chose a lot of interesting texts which we read chronologically. she bent over backward to make it not entirely western based; i'm not sure if this was a good or bad thing. i think femtexts 2 will be a lot more interesting to me, but tally was an easy grader, we had some good discussions and i was opened up to new vocabulary about how to consider the female experience. i wished it had been a bigger part of my semester, but a once-a-week class just didn't make that big an impact. still, it's easy, interesting, and you meet some cool people and consider different ideas.
She is no doubt very nice and welling to help. In terms of lecture classes (roman art and architecture), I end up taking photos of the slides because she didn't post it online and It's not easy finding them in books either. she assigned 4 books and I bought them all... very sad that I didn't read most of them, I just wished I didn't buy them. One of the essay on the final is about the book. I also took the her first year English, for some reason she is very easy on the first years. NO "slip on the face" in papers like most English prof. would. Her English class feels more like a culture study class with a mix of art class.
Kampen's lectures were always "politically correct," & no one challenged these views even as one had to listen to students drivel on about queer studies. her lectures & use of slides were supurb but her grading was difficult & random. she does not accept excuses for incomplete work
I have taken twelve art history courses at Columbia, and if I were to pick one to drop, this would be the one. Kampen is nice, yes, she lectures well, that is true, but she is very unfair. She does not give slide lists, and the TA's, who were surely the least helpful TA's I have ever had, certainly did nothing to remedy the situation. Of course, she does not give you all of the information for the slides during the lectures, and you are responsible for spending time in Avery finding all of the images that are not on the website. Unless you are truly interested in Roman art and architecture, I would not take this class. ***These corrections were sent to CULPA: "Kampen has very clear slide lists and slides online. She also puts some of her lectures on Courseworks. No TA's."
Tally is the most amazing professor at Columbia. Her knowledge of Roman art is immense (except she never remembers the dates for everything). But that isnt a big deal. Lectures were always really interesting, and I had no trouble staying awake, which I sometimes do in a slides/lecture class. She is always available for her students to talk to, and is incredibly sympathetic, understanding, and humerous. She is advising me for my thesis now, and I really enjoy every minute I spend working with her. Take a class with her if you can, you will love the experience and you will love her!
Tally is one of the best professors that Columbia/Barnard has to offer. She's enthusiastic, knowledgable and intelligent. She also makes an effort to get to know her students. Take any class that you can with her. She rocks.
Tally is sweet, sympathetic, hilarious, briliant, engaging, and she really cares about teaching even intro-class students. The problem with this class was mostly that it was too large, meaning that one day a week was just taking notes on Tally's or Professor Ortner's lecture (interrupted by a few annoying students contradicting the lecture or bringing their unfounded or egotistical opinions to the class's attention), and the second day was a discussion section in which people randomly gave their opinions about things but nothing of any value really came from hearing students talk out loud about their personal experiences. Take the 9am discussion section just to be with Tally, but be warned that even though she tries to veer students away from rambling or telling stories, this is mostly what people have to offer. The essays assigned for the class were far too random and you can't really connect your papers with what you read or learned in class. Also, Professor Ortner is not friendly nor funny like Tally, and her readings and lectures tend to walk the line between bearable and boring.
There is just no enough I can say about Tally. She is just what you would want your best friend's mother to be. She is sweet, caring, extremely funny, tells it like it is, and is not afraid to state the true facts. She is always willing to meet with students for extra help. Tally knows her subject so well that just listening to her think aloud will enlighten you. She talks fast and doesn't remember what she said before, so you can't ask her to repeat stuff, but the kid sitting next to you probably got what you missed and vise versa. The class is fascinating and with Tally teaching, you couldn't ask for a better combo.
Prof. Kampen is an excellent, engaging lecturer, with a wealth of knowledge in so many areas, though she passes the course over to other specialized professors for most of the sessions. It seems that her focus is in Ancient Greek, Roman, and Jewish work, but I've found her helpful across the board. One note: she hates people leaving mid-lecture-- don't do it! You won't want to anyway.... Plus, she incorporates NYC into the curriculum with Museum visits and relevant papers.
Natalie Kampen is one of the most engaging professors I've heard lecture. She "gets" her students, and speaks accordingly. Always willing to help out, she's pleasant to deal with. Take this course!!!
"Tally" Kampen: you rock.